Taxation without representation is still Tyranny

Let’s say a patient in obvious serious condition arrived by ambulance in my emergency department, dusky color, short of breath, unable to speak and clutching his chest. The paramedics have brought with them a folder with the patient’s medical history, list of meds, doctor’s names, etc. Also, they hand me their records with the account of the patient’s illness and why he called for an ambulance, the record of his blood pressure readings, pulse and respiratory rate, oxygen saturation, etc.

But instead of taking the time to review all this information and without doing a physical exam, I order a shot of penicillin and couple of Tylenol and prepare to discharge the patient back to whence he came. Did this unfortunate gentleman receive the medical care that he deserves? Can I honestly claim that he received the attention and care for which I am paid a substantial salary?

It is claimed that our government is a representative democracy. Most of the men and women that are to represent us and are paid exorbitant amounts of money, benefits and privileges to do so seem to think that they can cast votes without reading the bills that come before them, most recently the so-called “cap and trade bill” that was passed in the House or Representatives. They claim that they are sufficiently briefed by underlings and follow the direction of their party leaders and vote accordingly.

I ask you, is this representative government? Can we be confident that our congressmen and women are acting in our best interest if they don’t know first-hand what they are voting on? Of course not! No more than the doctor who leaps to conclusions without making every effort to understand the patient’s condition and diagnosis. If I were to approach my job the way most of our representatives do I would be stripped of my medical license and likely sued for millions, and deservedly so. How can we accept less of those who we trust with our security, our livelihoods, our freedoms and the future of our country? We have a right and a responsibility to demand more.

The web site Let Freedom Ring has begun a project that we should all support and should encourage our congressmen and senators to sign. They have produced a documentpledge-to-read that has been sent to all members of Congress that they are invited to sign (see illustration).

It is absurd that we should have to ask our representatives to do their jobs, but apparently that is what we’ve come to. Those that refuse to sign this pledge should be held accountable because we will then know that they have no interest in actually representing our interests or that of our country.
Let Freedom Ring has given representatives until July 20th to respond after which they will post a list of those who did and didn’t agree to the terms of the pledge. I will also post that list here at Dakota Voice.

Note: Reader comments are reviewed before publishing, and only salient comments that add to the topic will be published. Profanity is absolutely not allowed and will be summarily deleted. Spam, copied statements and other material not comprised of the reader’s own opinion will also be deleted.

  • Digg
  • Yahoo Buzz
  • Reddit
  • Yahoo Bookmarks
  • Delicious
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Windows Live Favorites
  • Technorati Favorites
  • NewsVine
  • Share/Bookmark
  • Guy Smylie
    Is reading the bill going to change their vote?I'm not confident that "Cap and Trade" wasn't what they were looking for.
    I think in the current state of events we have more of a case for "Taxation without Representation" when no one has read the tax bill. We might need a Reform Government Pledge!
  • Good point, Mr. Smylie. I agree that the pledge does not go far enough. Insisting that Congress actually read any bills that seek to "reform" health care is a good start but I think that they should be required to read ANY bill that they vote on. If they don't want to read a bill they can simply abstain and then answer to their constituents for their lassitude.

    I submit that virtually everything that this Congress votes on is a "tax bill." Everything they have done and seek to do will cost Americans more of their wealth or property. When government takes by force from those that produce it is a tax whatever cloak they may throw over it.
  • Steven Riley
    Think the pledge is great-simple and would just take them seconds to do. Our health care system needs help and I think everyone agrees with that. But it is not the looming threat that will undo our country's economy in the next couple of months as the Obama folks are trying to scare people into believing. The uninsured and underinsured must be addressed, but not sure total reform is whats needed. The pendulum doesn't have to swing to the other extreme to correct the problem. There are middle ground approaches where all those involved in health care delivery give up some.Even patients. If everyone adds to the pot, then soon it's full.

    I think our representative model is a good one, but human nature keeps getting in the way. I can't think of the last time I voted that I was really happy with my choices.
blog comments powered by Disqus